The Latest Music Issues Between SESAC and YouTube: What Creators Need to Know

If you’re a content creator or musician, you’ve probably heard of SESAC (Society of European Stage Authors and Composers) and YouTube. Both are key players in the digital world, particularly for those in the music industry. However, recent developments have raised concerns about licensing disputes and revenue sharing, which could have significant consequences for both creators and platforms alike.

What Is SESAC?

SESAC is one of the three major performing rights organizations (PROs) in the United States, alongside ASCAP and BMI. It helps songwriters, composers, and publishers collect royalties whenever their work is performed publicly—whether on TV, radio, live performances, or streaming platforms like YouTube.

Unlike ASCAP and BMI, which operate as non-profits, SESAC is a for-profit organization. This often gives it the flexibility to negotiate exclusive deals with platforms and rights holders, but it can also lead to more rigid negotiations when it comes to royalties and licensing fees.

YouTube’s Licensing Model

YouTube operates on a global scale, offering platforms for music videos, vlogs, educational content, and much more. It uses a content ID system that matches uploaded videos to copyrighted works and automatically monetizes or blocks content that uses those works without permission.

To keep music flowing on its platform, YouTube needs licensing agreements with PROs like SESAC. These agreements allow YouTube to legally offer music in videos and ensure that rights holders are compensated for their work.

The Crux of the Issue: Licensing Negotiations

Over the past few months, there have been reports of ongoing disputes between SESAC and YouTube regarding licensing terms. Some of the main sticking points include:

1. Royalties Disagreements: SESAC is reportedly seeking higher royalty rates for the music under its umbrella. They argue that the current revenue-sharing model undervalues the work of songwriters and composers. YouTube, on the other hand, is reluctant to increase these rates, especially considering the vast amount of music content it hosts.
2. Exclusive Licensing Challenges: SESAC has a history of negotiating exclusive deals with certain platforms. This could potentially limit the music catalog available on YouTube, as SESAC might push for certain works to be available only through premium services. This exclusivity can cause friction with YouTube’s broader strategy of offering a free, ad-supported experience alongside its YouTube Premium subscription.
3. Content ID and Rights Conflicts: There have been instances where SESAC-registered artists have raised concerns about YouTube’s Content ID system not accurately identifying their work or not paying them fairly. If SESAC believes that YouTube’s current system doesn’t adequately compensate artists, it could press for changes or more stringent licensing terms.

How This Affects Creators

For content creators on YouTube, this dispute could have several potential consequences:

• Fewer Music Options: If SESAC and YouTube can’t reach an agreement, creators may see certain music tracks become unavailable for use in their videos, limiting the library of songs they can legally include.
• Monetization Issues: Content creators who use SESAC-licensed music could face increased scrutiny, and their videos may be demonetized or even blocked depending on the outcome of negotiations.
• Potential Royalty Changes: If SESAC successfully negotiates higher royalty rates, it could lead to changes in YouTube’s revenue-sharing structure. While this might benefit musicians, it could also lead to higher costs for creators who use music in their videos.

Looking Forward: What Can Be Done?

Both SESAC and YouTube are important stakeholders in the digital music space, and it’s likely that they’ll eventually come to some sort of agreement. In the meantime, creators should:

• Stay Informed: Keep up with the latest news regarding SESAC and YouTube’s negotiations to understand how it may affect their content.
• Use YouTube’s Audio Library: YouTube offers a free music library that creators can use without worrying about copyright strikes. While it may not have the same range of popular songs, it’s a safe option while the SESAC issue remains unresolved.
• Explore Licensing Alternatives: Some creators may consider using other licensed music platforms like Epidemic Sound or Artlist to avoid potential issues with SESAC-licensed tracks.

Conclusion

The ongoing licensing dispute between SESAC and YouTube underscores the complex nature of digital music rights in the age of streaming. For content creators, staying on top of these developments is crucial to avoiding disruptions to their work. Whether you’re a musician, YouTuber, or a casual content creator, understanding how these negotiations impact the platform can help you navigate potential challenges and continue creating without hiccups.

Via-

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/music-videos-removed-youtube-copyright-dispute-1235115814