The History of the NFL MVP Award and Running Backs’ Role in It

The NFL MVP (Most Valuable Player) Award is one of the most prestigious honors in professional football. Presented annually by the Associated Press (AP), it recognizes the player who has made the most significant impact on their team’s success during the regular season. Over the years, the award has become a reflection of the league’s evolving style of play, often sparking debates over its criteria and the roles of various positions in earning this honor.

A Brief History of the NFL MVP Award

The AP NFL MVP Award was first introduced in 1957, with Jim Brown of the Cleveland Browns being its inaugural recipient. Brown, a running back, dominated the field with his unmatched power, agility, and field vision. His selection as the first MVP highlighted the importance of the running game during the early years of professional football.

In the NFL’s early decades, running backs were often the centerpieces of offensive strategy. Teams relied heavily on the ground game, and passing attacks were less developed compared to modern football. As a result, running backs frequently stood out as the most valuable players, leading to their dominance in the MVP race during the mid-20th century.

However, as the league shifted toward pass-heavy offenses in the late 20th and 21st centuries, quarterbacks began to take center stage. This transition is reflected in the MVP award’s history, with quarterbacks winning the majority of the awards in recent decades.

Running Backs Who Have Won the NFL MVP

To date, running backs have won the MVP award 18 times out of its more than 60-year history. Some of the most memorable winners include:

• Jim Brown: The first MVP and the only player to win it three times as a running back (1957, 1958, and 1965).
• O.J. Simpson: The first player to rush for over 2,000 yards in a single season (1973).
• Walter Payton: Known as “Sweetness,” he was awarded in 1977 for his unmatched versatility.
• Barry Sanders: Shared the 1997 MVP with Brett Favre after rushing for 2,053 yards.
• Adrian Peterson: The last running back to win the award in 2012, rushing for 2,097 yards just a year after a devastating ACL injury.

These players exemplified exceptional talent and were often the focal points of their respective offenses.

Why Running Backs Are Rarely MVPs Today

The decline in running backs winning the MVP award is tied to several factors:

1. Shift to Pass-Heavy Offenses: Modern NFL offenses are built around the passing game. Quarterbacks now have higher usage rates and directly impact a team’s success more than ever before.
2. Quarterbacks’ Value: The quarterback position is seen as the most important on the field. They are responsible for orchestrating plays, reading defenses, and leading comebacks. This intrinsic value makes them frequent MVP candidates.
3. Running Back by Committee: Many teams no longer rely on a single bell-cow running back. Instead, they distribute carries among multiple players, reducing individual stats and perceived value.
4. Longevity and Durability: Running backs often face short career spans and injuries due to the physical demands of their position. This limits their ability to produce MVP-caliber seasons consistently.
5. Advanced Analytics: Metrics like QBR (Quarterback Rating) and EPA (Expected Points Added) highlight quarterbacks’ contributions, while running backs’ value is sometimes seen as more replaceable.

Why Running Backs Can Still Win the MVP

Despite these challenges, running backs can still capture the MVP title under certain conditions:

• Historic Performances: Adrian Peterson’s 2012 season is a prime example. His near-record-breaking 2,097 rushing yards following a severe injury was an extraordinary achievement.
• Team Reliance: If a team’s offense revolves around a running back and they lead their team to the playoffs, this can boost their candidacy.
• Dual-Threat Abilities: Running backs who excel as receivers, such as Christian McCaffrey, can stand out by contributing significantly to both the run and pass games.

Saquon Barkley and the 2024 MVP Race

In 2024, Saquon Barkley has reignited the conversation about running backs in the MVP race. Now with the Philadelphia Eagles, Barkley has had a stellar season, averaging 126.5 rushing yards per game and leading the Eagles to a 10-2 record. His explosive performances, combined with a dominant offensive line, have made him a frontrunner alongside quarterbacks like Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson.

Barkley’s MVP odds surged dramatically after a career-best performance in Week 13, jumping from 75/1 to 5/1. To truly contend for the award, he might need to achieve something historic, such as breaking Eric Dickerson’s single-season rushing record of 2,105 yards or surpassing Chris Johnson’s 2,509 scrimmage yards from 2009. Additionally, the Eagles’ success as a team will weigh heavily, as MVP winners typically play for top playoff seeds.

Outlook for Barkley and Running Backs in the MVP Race

While the odds remain against Barkley due to the league’s quarterback bias, his electrifying season highlights the value a dominant running back can bring. If the Eagles continue their surge and Barkley breaks significant records, he could challenge the 11-year quarterback MVP streak and join the ranks of great backs like Peterson and Sanders.

Barkley’s campaign is not just a testament to his talent but also a nod to the enduring legacy of running backs in NFL history. Whether he claims the MVP or not, his performance has ensured that running backs remain part of the conversation in a quarterback-driven era.

Here are the references used for the blog post:

1. Pro Football Reference: Detailed historical data on NFL MVP winners, including the number of running backs who have won the award and their performance stats. Pro Football Reference​NFL.com.
2. Fox Sports: Insight into Saquon Barkley’s current MVP campaign with the Philadelphia Eagles, his recent performance surge, and odds in the 2024 race. Fox Sports​FOX Sports.
3. NBC Sports: Coverage of Barkley’s 2024 season highlights, the Eagles’ success, and the role of running backs in the MVP conversation. NBC Sports​NBC Sports Philadelphia.

These references provide both historical context and updated information about the ongoing NFL MVP race.

Share on Facebook

Post on X

Follow us

Save

Related:

Saquon Barkley’s Anticipated October 20th, 2024 Stats Against the Giants as an Eagles Running Back